What can I do if my new owner-occupied house has a hidden defect?
It may be the case that you discover a defect in your new owner-occupied house that you did not see before the handover. If you cannot use your home normally because of this defect, the seller often has to pay for the damage if they knew about the defect. Report the defect to the seller and ask for a solution.
Go straight to
Check if the seller is responsible
Step 1Sometimes you notice that something is wrong with your owner-occupied house after the handover. If you could not have discovered this before the handover, it is a hidden defect.
Sometimes the seller is responsible for the defect. This means they must repair the defect or pay for the repair. The seller may be responsible if:
- you cannot use your home normally because of the defect
- the seller knew about the defect but did not tell you
No normal use
The purchase contract often states that the home must have the ‘properties needed for normal use’. It may be the case that you cannot use your home normally because of the defect. For example, due to a leak or poor foundations. That means there is a good chance the seller is responsible and must pay for the repair.
Defect not reported
When selling a home, the seller must report all defects to the buyer. This is called the duty to inform. If the seller does not do this while they knew about the defect, they must pay the repair costs. As the buyer, you must prove that the seller knew about the defect but did not tell you.
It may be the case that the seller did not know about the defect but should have known, or knew there was a risk. For example, there was contaminated soil and they said nothing about this risk. They must then also pay compensation. You must prove that the seller should have known about the defect.
The buyer’s duty to check
As a buyer, you must also check for problems yourself. If you did a lot of checks before buying the home and asked a lot of questions, there is a greater chance that the seller must pay for damage you find after the purchase. A building survey helps to prove that you checked properly. If you did not do enough checks, there is less chance that the seller must pay for damage caused by a hidden defect.
The older a home is, the greater the chance that something is broken. The older the home, the more checks you need to do. A building survey is recommended.
Sometimes the purchase contract includes an old age clause. This says that you know the home is old and that there is therefore a greater risk of defects. It also says that you accept that risk. Because of this clause, the seller is less likely to have to pay for the damage.
Talk to the seller
Step 3After you report the hidden defect, try to find a solution together. The seller may want to repair the defect or you may agree on how to divide the costs.
It is important to write down the agreements. A mediator may be able to help with this.
You must give the seller the chance to repair the hidden defect within a reasonable time. The seller may do this themselves or with help from a company. If you do not give the seller that chance and repair it yourself, you will probably not be able to get the repair costs back from the seller.
Give the seller a final chance by letter
Step 4If you and the seller cannot agree or the seller does not respond, you must give the seller one last chance. This means giving the other person a final written warning. You can use our sample letter for giving the seller a final chance about hidden defects in an owner-occupied house.
Ask the court for a solution
Step 5If you cannot agree with the seller, you can go to court.
If the damage is more than € 25,000, you need a lawyer. If the damage is less, a lawyer is not required. Even so, it is often sensible to get help from a lawyer because this is usually a complicated situation.
If you have legal expenses insurance, you can ask them for advice.
Can I get all costs back from the seller?
Can I get all costs back from the seller?
Usually this is not possible. You are not allowed to make a profit by making the seller pay for the repair. This means you can often only get back part of the costs from the seller.
The seller must sell you a home that is suitable for normal use. If something is broken, the home is usually better after the repair because you use modern materials. Those materials will last for a long time. Without the repair, you would not have had this improvement.